top of page
Logo 1.png

Your Best Engineer Isn’t Automatically Your Next Leader

Matt Stephenson
Oct 28
3 min read

You have a brilliant engineer in your team.


They’re the person others turn to when a problem is difficult. They understand the systems, make good decisions and consistently deliver.


A leadership role becomes available. You want to recognise their contribution, give them an opportunity to progress and make sure you don’t lose them.


So you promote them.


A few months later, things aren’t going quite as you expected.


They’re still involved in the technical detail. They’re reviewing every decision, picking up difficult pieces of work themselves and finding it hard to give the rest of the team the attention they need.


You start to wonder whether they were ready for the role.


But perhaps the more useful question is whether you helped them get ready.


A different job needs different skills


Being a strong engineer and being a strong leader are different skills.


Of course, technical experience can be hugely valuable in a technology leadership role.


It helps you understand the work, build credibility and make informed decisions.


But leadership also requires you to develop people, set direction, make space for others to make decisions and accept that you can’t personally be involved in everything.


That last part can be uncomfortable.


When I first moved into leadership, one of the biggest challenges for me was accepting that I couldn’t stay in the same level of detail across a much broader remit. I was suddenly responsible for areas where I wasn’t necessarily the expert. Later, I also had to become comfortable being accountable for things I wasn’t directly delivering myself.


Those are significant changes in how you work and how you measure your own contribution.


Not everyone wants to let go of the keyboard


For some people, the appeal of engineering is the work itself. They enjoy solving technical problems, learning new technologies and creating things.


Moving away from that work can feel like giving up the thing they’ve spent years becoming good at. That doesn’t mean they lack ambition. It might mean they want to develop their expertise and influence without taking on a people management role.


Businesses need to think carefully about the career paths they offer. If the only way to gain recognition, influence or better pay is to become a manager, people can find themselves moving into roles that don’t play to their strengths.


A senior technical career path can help you retain expertise while allowing people to progress in a direction that suits them.


Preparation should start before the promotion


Even when someone does want to move into leadership, I think businesses often leave it too late to start preparing them.


We put someone into a new role and then help them work out how to do it. Some support at that point is essential, but there are opportunities to start much earlier.


Could they mentor a colleague?


Could they take responsibility for a small piece of strategic thinking and make a recommendation?


Could they lead a piece of work involving people from different teams?


Could they take on a small amount of people management, with support, to see whether they enjoy it and have an aptitude for it?


These opportunities help people stretch themselves. They also help both the individual and the business understand whether a bigger leadership role is the right next step.

And if it is, the promotion becomes less of a leap into the unknown.


Developing your replacement


This is also part of succession planning.


I think one of the responsibilities of a leader is to look for the people who could follow them and give those people opportunities to grow.


That doesn’t mean promising someone your job. It means recognising potential, understanding what they want from their career and helping them develop the skills they may need next.


It’s good for the individual. It’s good for the business. And, as my podcast guest Marian Kamenistak points out, it can also give you the freedom to grow into your next role.


A conversation with Marian


I recently discussed these challenges with Marian Kamenistak, a fractional CTO, mentor and founder of the Engineering Leaders Community.


We talked about the transition from engineer to leader, why letting go of technical work can be so difficult, and how businesses can do a better job of developing their future leaders.


You can watch the full conversation on The Common Sense CTO YouTube channel.



You can find out more about Marian Kamenistak and the Engineering Leaders Community.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page